Eddie & Sam's N.Y Pizza
open now, until 22:00
Pizza place Café Restaurant
New York Pizza Shop
Holiday Hours: CLOSED from 12/18/23-01/02/24 Update description
Review Eddie & Sam's N.Y Pizza
Loading comments-box...
Nicole M. 2014-06-29Authentic N.Y. Pizza!!! I'm from Philly/NJ and have searched for REAL pizza in te Tampa area. Not much luck until I went to this place!!! We will...
Chris W. H. 2014-06-21Excellent NY pizza and gelato in downtown Tampa. The crust passed my NY crust test - fold the slice in half - the crust should not crack if prepared...
Avry R. 2014-06-12As I sit in the gelato portion of this restaraunt I think 2 things: "man this feels like New York" and "ive never been to New York....but this has to...
Michelle Kester F. 2019-01-15Amazing NY pizza w/ a huge selection of slices/ varieties. Us NY’er’s loved it!
Sha V. 2018-11-25Amazing Pizza and fast service. Overall great experience with my family.
Sulain J. 2018-10-29Best Pizza in town
Nathan G. 2018-09-23Best pizza in Tampa and giant slices
Briel Kristina R. 2018-09-16LOVE LOVE LOVE IT
Le J. 2018-08-05Best pizza in Tampa hand tossed!! LOL just like NY ❤️
Erika M. 2018-08-03These people are rude racist from the owner on down to the staff. I think this needs to be reviewed by the NAACP.
Bubba C. 2018-08-01Everyone from Ny if u are willing to do the 1 hour drive from Orlando to Tampa to get the realest Ny pizza like my brother and I do sometimes 2x a...
LaLa L. 2018-07-30This is real NYC Pizza!
Derrick A N. 2018-07-28The food was good, the service was great.
Pat P. 2018-07-26Great Slices!!! Drove 2 hours to go back for the second day in a row. Might go back for a 3rd :-)
Jeffrey H. 2018-07-05The place rocks. I didn't know there was a line, but it moved quickly. July 4th . I wanted to order a large pie, however, once I got closer and saw...
Chandler E. 2018-07-04Dough and marinara sauce are SO delicious.
E.D. B. 2018-07-02Visiting Tampa from Atlanta and found Eddie & Sam’s on Yelp saw reviews & pictures so I decided to stop by. Arguably best pizza I ever had!!! Staff...
Christy R. 2018-07-02It was my first visit to Eddie & Sam’s N.Y Pizza and the experience was awesome. The servers were nice, attentive and fast. I got the chicken...
Don S. 2018-07-02Stopped there for something cold with my little son and it was a very nice atmosphere. I did not get to try the pizza, next visit will, but I have...
Angie C. 2018-07-02I will come back to Tampa just to eat here!! Pizza was delicious & great desserts
Popularity of Eddie & Sam's N.Y Pizza
Social Media Popularity Score: This value is based on the number of visitors, checkins, and likes on Facebook in the last few months.
Most activity in April:
Eddie & Sam's N.Y Pizza has a total of 22235 visitors (checkins) and 6331 likes.
20 reviews of Eddie & Sam's N.Y Pizza.
Average grade
4.7
av 5.
Dio Modern Mediterranean
Samaria Cafe